🍞 What to bake for Thanksgiving, and when to start


Your easy Thanksgiving sourdough playbook

I spent the week handing loaves to friends around town and baking cookies for my son’s Thanksgiving lunch. Baking for other people this time of year is hard to beat. But honestly, baking for the big meal itself might be the one thing that really does.

So here’s the plan!

Big breads for the center of the table, a few smaller ones in a supporting roll (😉), and two sweets.

Each comes with a schedule, so you know what to start this weekend and what can wait until Thursday morning.

In this week's newsletter:

  • Big Breads: Hop miche, walnut & cran, sunflower & sesame, 90-rye
  • Accent Breads: Soft sourdough rolls, green olive filoncini
  • Sweets: Cocoa galette crust, discard chocolate chip cookies
  • What I'm Reading And Watching: Maurizio on Sourhouse podcast; Is an AI Agent Coming for Our Sourdough Starter?

🍞 Hop Miche (bread with beer)

Dark, rich, insanely flavorful—this miche has taken my top spot for Thanksgiving. It goes extremely well with anything on the table, and it looks stunning.

How To Schedule This Bread

Start making this loaf two days before and finish baking it the day before Thanksgiving. The flavor continues to develop as the loaf rests overnight, and it'll be perfect for slicing just before the big meal.

🍞 Walnut + Cranberry Sourdough

Given the flavor combination, this one's a natural—and it just happens to be one of my all-time favorite breads, too.

How To Schedule This Bread

Mix, bulk ferment, and shape the dough the day before Thanksgiving early in the day. On Thanksgiving, heat the oven and bake the loaves first thing, then let cool and rest until you slice them later in the day.

Sunflower + Sesame Sourdough

Not your first thought when pairing seeds, but lemme tell ya, this one is certainly something special.

How To Schedule This Bread

Same as the walnut + cranberry loaf—mix, bulk ferment, and shape the dough the day before Thanksgiving early in the day. On Thanksgiving, heat the oven and bake the loaves first thing, then let cool and rest until you slice them later in the day.

🍞 Sourdough 90-Rye Bread

Super flavorful, this earthy, rustic, and just stunning loaf will gracefully take all the attention at the table and yet not apologize for any of it.

Baking Schedule Tips

Bake this rye bread a day or two (or heck, even three) before Thanksgiving, and it'll keep well (and even improve) as it rests.

🍞 Super Soft Sourdough Rolls (And a Baking Schedule)

My favorite soft rolls for a gathering, especially Thanksgiving, are soft, incredibly flavorful, and the perfect side for the big meal.

🔴 Be sure to check out my complete YouTube walkthrough on the recipe page!

Baking Schedule Tips

Rolls are best the day they're baked. Here's how I make them for Thanksgiving:

  • Two days before, at night: Make the overnight levain
  • The day before: Mix the dough, bulk ferment, shape the rolls, and place them in the baking pan. Let sit out for 1 hour, then cover and refrigerate.
  • Thanksgiving: Take out early in the morning and let proof on the counter until they are puffy; bake later in the morning and let rest until dinner. Briefly warm in a warm oven before serving.

Green Olive Filoncini

These are like the ultimate breadstick—though, they're quite a bit bigger, perfect for tearing and to eat with gravy.

Baking Schedule Tips

Mix these pointy sticks the day before Thanksgiving, then bulk-ferment the dough overnight in the refrigerator. On the big day, take them out in the morning, shape them (so fun), proof them, and bake them well before everyone arrives. Reheat in a warm oven, if desired.

🍎 Sourdough Discard Cocoa Galette

This one is a stunner and works so well with fall fruit (like the pictured red pear).

How To Schedule This Galette/Pie Crust

Make the crust this weekend and pop it into the freezer. Then take it out 2 days before Thanksgiving to refrigerate overnight, and make your galette or pie of choice the next day (the day before Thanksgiving).

🍪 Sourdough Discard Choc Chip Cookies

I made CCCs for my son's Thanksgiving lunch this week, and they were a huge hit. I really don't think there's ever a time they're not the perfect little treat.

How To Schedule

I make this dough and then freeze half. This way, I can make half a batch for one evening and have fresh cookies on any other lazy holiday afternoon, too.

🍞 "Wintertime Sourdough" in my Cookbook

Have my cookbook? Flip to page 187 and make my Wintertime Sourdough with sage, cranberries, and toasted pecans—an uncommon combination that's seriously delightful and screams winter.


🛟 2 Ways I Can Help You For Thanksgiving


📙 What I'm Reading and Watching

​Bake This Book — Podcast, Maurizio Leo, The Perfect Pizza. I was recently on the wonderful Bake This Book podcast with the folks over at Sourhouse, talking all things sourdough, fermentation, and pizza.

​Is an 'A.I. Agent' Coming for Our Sourdough Starter? (NYT) As you can imagine, I'm certainly not in favor of this, but I do understand what they're going for with this product. But it does feel like it takes all the joy out of baking, for me at least.

Happy holiday!

​Join me in the member's community, master sourdough, and get baker's perks.

Thank you for subscribing 🩶. Sent from Maurizio at The Perfect Loaf, 8100 Wyoming Blvd NE Ste M4, #343, Albuquerque, NM 87113.
​Unsubscribe · Preferences​

The Perfect Loaf 🍞

Want to make bakery-quality sourdough bread from home? Subscribe for the best sourdough guides and recipes to take your bread from ordinary to incredible.

Read more from The Perfect Loaf 🍞

Bread Baker's Gift Guide My newly updated bread bakers' gift guide for 2026 is here! I spend all year trying new baking equipment to make things easier and more consistent here at home, and only the items I truly love make it to this list. A few cool new things this year: A smaller but very capable dough mixer A new and very great scale Excellent Sicilia bread and pizza flour My favorite dough thermometer ...and more! This year, there's a mix of smaller wares and a few bigger items, and any...

Pizza night, plus pumpkin scones It’s book launch week around here, and tomorrow (Saturday) is the last day to get the bonus pack with The Perfect Pizza. More on that just below. But launch week still needs breakfast, right? Have a lingering can of puree? (I’ve made these with pumpkin, sweet potato (!), and even butternut squash.) Put it to good use this weekend in these whole-grain scones. They’re tall, flaky, rich, and just a little sweet. I think they might be my favorite scone. In this...

The Perfect Pizza is out today It’s here. After three years and a few hundred test bakes, The Perfect Pizza is out today. Every recipe is naturally leavened and built for any oven you have (from home ovens to outdoor gas to wood-fired). This dough and these toppings are recipes in the book! If you pre-ordered, thank you! Your book should arrive today or tomorrow. And if you’ve been waiting for it to be real, it’s real! Order by Saturday and the bonus pack is still yours: scaling spreadsheets...